Green Tea and Iron Absorption
Anaemia Study Discover Twist
A green tea and iron study found that it reduces absorption and is
bad for anaemia sufferers. But a 2005 study found that regular drinkers are not
affected.
If you
are prone to iron deficiency or anaemia, you may have a dilemma of whether or not to drink
tea.
It is not a straightforward decision.
Scientific evidence is mixed. While it is widely recognised that drinking tea
causes malabsorption, large scale population studies point otherwise.
In a while, you will understand why scientific studies offer contradicting
results and how to take effective precautions against it.
There are two kinds of dietary iron: heme and non-heme.
Heme iron, found in meat, fish and poultry, is absorbed by the body very
efficiently.
Non-heme iron, found in flours, cereals, and fortified grain products, is
more difficult to absorb.
Tea tannins contain antioxidants that offer many health benefits. They
protect from metal pollutants by combining with them, rendering them
harmless.
Could the same process interfere with the absorption of dietary iron?
Scientists in the Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University in Denmark
found that this is the case.
A green tea and iron study published in the March 2001 edition of the
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition reports that green tea extract reduces the absorption of non-heme
iron by 25%.
The 2001 green tea and iron study is not unique. Several other studies report
similar findings. Tea affects food consumption and utilisation.
It is great if you are trying to lose weight, but bad news for those prone to
anaemia.
Now, does it mean that being a healthy, long-term tea drinker makes you
vulnerable to iron deficiency?
Surprisingly, the answer is no. Here comes the twist: studies suggest that
drinking tea for an extended period of time does not reduce iron absorption
either in rats or humans.
For example, the 1992 population study conducted by Mehta found negative
correlations between drinking tea and anaemia.
How strange?
It is speculated that long-term consumption triggers a defensive mechanism in
the body that neutralises the harmful effects of tannins.
A 2005 green tea and iron study conducted by Kim offers one plausible
explanation.
The scientists found that rats drinking tea for 5 days have a heavier parotid
gland and therefore secrets more proline-rich proteins (PRP) in saliva.
70% of saliva secreted by humans are PRP.
PRP combines with tannins, preventing them from reducing iron absorption.
Put another way, if you drink tea occasionally, having your meal with tea
can be harmful.
But if you are a healthy, long-term drinker, your body adapted by secreting a high level of proteins in the saliva, which form complexes with tannins,
rendering them harmless.
Cool eh?
Taking Effective Precautions
To put this into perspective, many foods and beverages also reduce the amount
of non-heme iron we absorb.
These include coffee, dairy, fiber, eggs and some chocolate. Calcium can
impair the absorption of both non-heme and heme iron.
Therefore if you need more iron, you should avoid these foods. But if you
have too much iron, you should eat more of them.
If you suffer from or are prone to iron deficiency, the following might
help:
- Avoid drinking many cups of tea and coffee, especially black tea, and even
some herbal varieties.
- Add lemon juice to your cuppa. Some people prefer milk, but milk won’t help
you absorb more iron - adding lemon does.
- If you drink loose tea, brew it half-strength. Add 2 to 3 grams of loose
leaves per cup. Avoid full-strength tea.
- Avoid drinking tea with a meal or an hour afterwards.
- Avoid drinking tea if you are experiencing a period or blood
loss.
Samman S, Sandstrom B, Toft MB, Bukhave K, Jensen M, Sorensen SS, Hansen M
(2001). Green tea or rosemary extract added to foods reduces nonheme-iron
absorption. Am J Clin Nutr. 2001 Mar;73(3):607-12.
Hee-Seon Kim and Dennis D. Miller (2005). Nutrient Interactions and Toxicity
Proline-Rich Proteins Moderate the Inhibitory Effect of Tea on Iron Absorption
in Rats. The American Society for Nutritional Sciences J. Nutr. 135:532-537,
March 2005
Mehta, S. W., Pritchard, M. E. & Stegman, C. (1992) Contribution of
coffee and tea to anemia among NHANES II participants. Nutr. Res.
12:209-222.
Back to Top of Green Tea and Iron
Back to Green Tea Side Effects Main Page
Back to Amazing Green Tea Home
|
In the tea world,
you can never know too much.
Every month, I put pen to paper a letter to my tea friends worldwide.
Amazing Green Tea Newsletter
is dedicated to solving problems
every tea drinker faces.
|
 |